PDA

View Full Version : Game Red Dead Redemption Discussion


joefro
05-19-2010, 10:49 PM
Read Dead Redemption came out on 18 May 2010 on Xbox 360 and PS3. It's a really fun game that can be described as, an open world, third-person shooter, based in an early 1900s American setting.
Lauch trailer:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3gBctl1h_2o
The game was developed by Rockstar San Diego (Red Dead Revolver, Midnight Club) and published by Rockstar Games.

It features both a robust single player mode and a massive multiplayer mode. In the single player you can do various different missions, such as lassoing and taming wild horses, having a duel with a wild man, stopping criminals and gangs in their hideouts. You can also go hunting and play lots of different games such as, poker, five finger fillet, horseshoes, etc.

In multiplayer you can either play free roam, free-for-all, or gang matches. In free roam you can explore the entire game world, much like GTA IV. You can also go to different gang hideouts and wipeout the gangs to gain experience. In free-for-all and gang matches you play the standard, death matches and objective games. A unique feature to the RDR multiplayer modes is the standoff at the beginning of each match. Whoever wins the standoff gets a head-start on the match.

Free roam mode is my favorite mode to play. A cool thing that you can do is form a posse. When you form a posse your posse leader can set waypoints for you and you can also spawn near your other posse members. This is really helpful because the game map is huge and travel by horse takes a while. You can also travel by transportion spots, which are basically teleporters. The only thing I don't like about posses is the fact that you have to start a new one with each game you go into. I thought that it was going to be a more traditional clan system.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5KbBG31F5aM

The multiplayer also features a very in-depth ranking system. As you rank up you gain different mounts, characters, weapons and titles. The first mounts and weapons are weak but as you level you get some awesome ones.

Rockstar has also announced that they will be adding in co-op missions to the game as dlc in June, free of charge.

This game is awesome. I was expecting it to be good, but not this good. My one complaint is the glitches online. The game suffers from an invisibility glitch where some players start to go invisible when playing online. It is really bad. I don't see how this made it through a beta test with none of the testers noticing it. Hopefully they patch it soon. Here's a Kotaku article that explains the glitch: link (http://kotaku.com/5542914/invisibility-bugs-vexing-red-dead-redemption-players)


Anyone else enjoying this game?

[SPOILER-BOX]I also found this on Kotaku.
If anyone is on the fence about which version to get, I'd suggest going with 360 on this one. Supposedly the PS3 edition suffers from frame rate issues, resolution issues and other graphic issues. The game runs at a lower resolution on PS3, 640p vs 720p on 360. Even though the 360 edition was the lead platform, the screen shots comparisons don't look too bad. The PS3 does suffer a lot with foliage and grass rendering. The 360 version has grass all over the place and the PS3 has about 50% of the grass on the ground. It's a pretty noticeable difference.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=21355476&postcount=704

P.S. Not trying to start a flame war. I own both systems and own lots of multiplatform games on PS3. I'm just trying to inform the people who look for stuff like this.[/SPOILER-BOX]

Palle
05-19-2010, 11:07 PM
My brother's still deciding between this and LP2, so we haven't committed yet, but I've liked what I've seen. Any word on a patch for the invisibility bug?

joefro
05-19-2010, 11:18 PM
No word on a patch yet. (though Rockstar is working on fixing it) That is really aggravating though. I need to update my post to reflect that.

amtalx
05-20-2010, 12:04 AM
I finished Alan Wake tonight (f*cking awesome) so I'll need something else to play soon. One question though, how similar is it to GTA? GTA is fun for a hot minute, until you realize how the driving is awful and missions are repetitive.

joefro
05-20-2010, 12:21 AM
The controllers are similar to GTA, which means that they are pretty horrible. The auto-aim is ridiculous and it should be banned online. The horse riding is really fun, but the controllers are stupid. You have to tap A to make your horse run. Your horse has a stamina bar and he gets really pissed if you drain it, at which point he throws you off of him.

I haven't really gotten into the single player too much, I've played maybe three or four hours. The missions have so far been, "Go kill X and bring him back alive" or "Go round up X animal." There is a lot of different types of missions to choose from and tons of side missions. I think I've only done four or five story missions and about ten side missions.

I also can't wait to get Alan Wake after I'm done with RDR single player.

Powder Keg
05-20-2010, 01:14 AM
First impression? Take GTA, and make it boring.

I think the single player is decent so far, but there sure is a lot of nothing to do in multiplayer, and the game-old sloppy GTA controls are still around. (mostly talking about movement here, the rest is fine)

I feared the transition from a GTA clone going from vehicles, high flying, crashes, and explosives would translate into the west...and unfortunately, seems that the transition I was worried about wasn't done too well.


My biggest question is, how do you have less options in a newer game? You could customize a lot of stuff in GTA IV (and I wasn't even the biggest fan of that, Saints Row 2 blew it out of the water) and in a newer game you can't change jack? Rockstar probably just isn't giving a shit, as every single website/magazine is going to rate all of their games high just because of their rep.

joefro
05-20-2010, 03:24 AM
There's a good bit of stuff to do in multiplayer, you just need to search around the map to find some of it (which can be a real drag). I like the challenges in multiplayer, they give me stuff to do. My buddy and I just spend a half hour searching for eight Butterfly Weed to complete a challenge. The challenges give you a good amount of XP also.

Outrider
05-20-2010, 10:27 AM
Probably not getting this soon, but I'll keep an eye on it for a price drop. I've heard great things, and I've kind of been hoping for somebody to expand upon the idea of an open-world western after the mostly-good Gun.

Delete
05-20-2010, 10:35 AM
I finished Alan Wake tonight (f*cking awesome) so I'll need something else to play soon. One question though, how similar is it to GTA? GTA is fun for a hot minute, until you realize how the driving is awful and missions are repetitive.

Kinda off topic, but you mean the Demo right?

amtalx
05-20-2010, 10:49 AM
Kinda off topic, but you mean the Demo right?

Demo of Alan Wake or GTAIV? If you're talking about Alan Wake, that didn't have a demo, and it was released Tuesday. If you're talking about GTAIV...that didn't have a demo either. :p

Powder Keg
05-20-2010, 01:12 PM
With GTA I couldn't stand the single player, but loved the insanity of multiplayer. Cops and Crooks was great, even free roam you could do a lot because there were a ton of vehicles around.

I tried multiplayer again for this today, and it just isn't that fun. You think spawn camping is bad in some games...you should see this. I literally watched as 3 people appeared in front of me on screen and killed them all as soon as they spawned. Grab bag looks awesome, but that's about it...

Zeek123
05-20-2010, 04:57 PM
I'm not much of a multiplayer guy, but I'll give it a shot or two. I'll probably really get into it after some co-op missions are released.

I've played through just a little bit of the single player. Haven't really had time to do much. I like the idea of breaking in your horse and building trust with it and whatnot.

The southern accents haven't really gotten to me... yet.

It looks pretty good for the most part. People look ugly, but that's a Rockstar thing. The sky looks great though. From morning to night, always an eye opener.

McLaughlin
05-20-2010, 07:36 PM
That invisible-stuff glitch got patched (http://kotaku.com/5544100/rockstar-patches-red-dead-redemption-invisibility-glitch?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+kotaku%2Ffull+(Kotaku)).

Delete
05-21-2010, 01:38 AM
Demo of Alan Wake or GTAIV? If you're talking about Alan Wake, that didn't have a demo, and it was released Tuesday. If you're talking about GTAIV...that didn't have a demo either. :p

Didn't know Alan Wake was out already :o

Thought it was coming out next year, definitely gotta pick that one up.

joefro
05-21-2010, 02:49 AM
I wish that you could turn friendly fire off in free roam. Some people are dicks and constantly kill you. I know that it is a public game, but come on. It's really fun to ride around with sixteen people taking out gangs and going hunting.

Powder Keg
05-21-2010, 06:19 AM
I wish that you could turn friendly fire off in free roam. Some people are dicks and constantly kill you. I know that it is a public game, but come on. It's really fun to ride around with sixteen people taking out gangs and going hunting.

Doesn't that automatically turn off when you make your own posse?


Even my friend who insisted we all get this thinks it's really boring. Thankfully I only really paid about 30 bucks for this so hopefully I can get a good credit. >_>

joefro
05-23-2010, 02:53 AM
Doesn't that automatically turn off when you make your own posse?


Nah, you can still betray your posse members.



After playing for a couple more days, I'm still having mixed feeling about the multiplayer. Sometimes I love free roam, sometimes I hate it. The challenges can be really fun, especially with some friends. Four of us got in a carriage tonight and went bird hunting which was pretty cool, and a little bit challenging. We also held out in a barn for about a half hour with each of us having a bounty of about $3000.

The multiplayer isn't the best around, but for the setting of the game and the technology they had back then, I don't think that Rockstar could have added much more to the experience.

Powder Keg
05-23-2010, 10:29 AM
They could have at least evolved the control/movement scheme a bit. I suppose in Rockstar's mind though, realism > gameplay.

I ended up trading my copy in. I ended up with the same amount I paid for it, so at least I dodged the bullet.