HUmar or HUcast?

[Clavat99]

Pros and cons of HUmar:

Pros: Can use more guns than HUcast. Has more appearance options than HUcast. Some MTP
--
Cons: Low ATA, Low MTP, much lower health than HUcast, cant use weapons and armor thats as strong as a HUcast.


Pros and cons of HUcast:

Pros: Highest HP in the game, auto-trap-vision, One of the highest ATAs in the game, Highest ATP in the game, One of the highest DFPs in the game, can use strongest weapons and armor, can use traps
--
Cons: No Techniques, traps are mostly useless


HUcasts are better Hunters than HUmars...Your argument has been rendered invalid.

[Chaos Rappy]

Once again, like in another post I made, the trap vision thing is almost completely negligible. All you need to do is use 1 Trap Vision item and you're good for an entire dungeon, and they're EXTREMELY cheap to buy too, not to mention how many you might get just randomly dropping everywhere.

Anyways, no I can't say I think your idea of HUcasts being better on just those bases. Your argument on HUcasts "having better armor" is basically null. The best armor in the game overall, the Noble Cloak, can be wielded by every class in the game, and is MUCH better than any CAST-specific armors, even for CASTs; even then, Mobius Plate is NOT that much stronger than Carabinier Armor, which HUmars CAN use.

HUmar 0, HUcast 0.

Ranged weaponry selection is fairly similar between both character types. HUmars get the better gunblade selections with the Emperor Axeon being the highest ATP Gunblade, but HUcasts get the Frigiand, the best common Gunblade [and therefore can have celeb], so that's in the air. Handgun selection is same, Laser Cannons is similar, but HUmars do have the advantage on bazookas, which isn't saying much. HUcasts end up getting the better end on Mechguns slightly with Blackhawk, but they're really not THAT much better than Twin Violets, which is all-class and has higher ATP and ATA than it. Rifles go to HUcast, unfortunately, because of Lavateinn. Overall, HUcasts do get the slight upper-hand on the certain selections they have, but you must remember, you're a Hunter, and melee is usually where you're going to be, not shooting.

HUmar 0, HUcast 1.

As far as BEING a Hunter is concerned, HUmars make up for their stat-lackages in being able to support themselves and others with boosting Techs like Shifta/Deband, which can help ease buff loads on support Forces, even if they can cast higher levels (really now, what's 5% extra ATP/MST when it means someone else can cast it instead of you?). HUmars' ability to use Techs really shines in solo mode, such as going through the Eternal Tower, where they can simply cast Resta to heal, buff themselves with S/D (which, might I add, closes the ATP/DFP gap between them and THEN some), and even cast Anti to take off statuses, which CASTs are limited to only being able to use items to do any of these, except buff, which they cannot even do themselves here. Online, with support forces and casting Jells and Zalures, any real differences between the two are hardly noticeable as far as ATA becomes, and even damage output. Another thing to mention that I don't think a lot of people even think to look up is that, until level 40 or so, HUmars will actually have more ATP than HUcasts. Try looking it up if you don't believe me. CASTs don't even get better until about level 40, and then they just retain only a step ahead of HUmars ATP-wise, which solo, is easily solved with Shifta.

HUmar 1, HUcast 1.

That's about all I can come up with from scratch. A thing to point out about your point about HUcasts getting access to stronger weapons than HUmar: which weapons would THOSE be? Humars and HUcasts both have access to virtually EVERY melee weapon in this game. HUcasts cannot wield any better weapons than HUmars can, and they don't make them look any better wielding them either.

My argument is now valid, and yours, challenged.

[pso_crash]

I think Humar is better a choice if you plan on soloing. Humars can use shifta to give themselves higher atp than Hucasts, and have more/better options when facing melee resistant enimies. Hucast on the other hand are better in groups where they can get buffs from a teammate. Traps are not as useless as people will have you believe. Fire traps can big a big help against big monsters with lots of hp(arkzeins) and ice traps are worth using if you are for crowd control if you are in a pinch. Overall I prefer Hucasts, but I think Humars are worth using.

Edit: Oh, it looks like Choasmaster00 already said it all.

[Clavat99]

Ive looked into this matter more and have come to this conclusion.

HUcasts are actually better for soloing because they have the higher DFP and HP, making them survival specialists. And their ATP can easily exceed 1000 with just a little bit of work. Personally, i think that if you are planning on going solo, HUcast is the best choice for just playing, and also the best choice for a tank on multiplayer. And a HUmar can also be a good solo choice, but they do better with friends around and can combine their slight buffing abilities and heals with another HUmar or a FO to stack boosts to the point where they are huge.

[HeartBreak301]

I say HUcast. When it comes to hunters it's all or nothing in my book.

[Chaos Rappy]

they have the higher DFP

Their DFP gap is nearly closed in with HUmar's Deband that they have access to in solo that HUcasts, without interference from Mags, do not. Besides, DFP is pretty hardly noticeable in SH unless you spend your entire build on it, and then you aren't going to be killing things as efficiently to do so. HUmars' higher EVP's combined with their good DFP make for better defensive survival, and the HP gap is almost just as neglicible when in SH, things take off about a hundred HP if you get hit the wrong way, especially in boss fights.

And their ATP can easily exceed 1000 with just a little bit of work.

And again, Shifta in solo closes that gap and more with HUmars' already fairly high ATP and the natural ability to cast Shifta themselves, making their SOLO damage better than that of CASTs. Casting one Shifta every room or two really isn't that big of a deal either, popping a fluid every now and again solves that issue quickly, but it'snot like CASTs don't have to guzzle down fluids themselves if they want to use PA's even remotely often compared to Humans or Newmans (especially Newmans).

Personally, i think that if you are planning on going solo, HUcast is the best choice for just playing, and also the best choice for a tank on multiplayer.

Now, see, MULTIPLAYER is an entirely different concept. Anyone else can fill in the gaps and help everyone else out, and most of the downsides for either class becomes transparent: a Zalure from a helpful force negates HUmars' abysmal ATA, and a Force's Shifta allows HUcasts to finally have more ATP than a solo HUmar. It's all really completely on the party how effective either class is played in that case.

And a HUmar can also be a good solo choice, but they do better with friends around and can combine their slight buffing abilities and heals with another HUmar or a FO to stack boosts to the point where they are huge.

I'd actually have to disagree. HUmars are better solo players if only because all their talents go away in multiplayer, except for their trash ATA, which is where multiplayer actually helps their case. Because of forces, their slight heals and buffs are null, and their ATP can now be beat by another HUcast of similar build because a Force Shiftas them both. HUmars still have the advantage on PP, though, but that hardly helps them. If you want PP efficiency, Newmans are where it's at.

[leviayurashyguy]

could've sworn i saw HH when i looked at Blue Bulletta, oh well

HUCAST has access to Vthra Weapon , Blackhawk, Lavateinn; three ranged weapons which are Celeb-able

HUCAST has access to THREE 7* Rifle

HUmar and HUCAST share same melee weapon pool EXCEPT for Ajax/Vanguard, non-Celeb-able Shield

HUCAST has 16 ATP (w/ mats) and 37 ATA (w/o) over HUmar. ATP difference is further increased after Shita

Kai casts Shifta

Mag casts Shifta

Midgul bestows Shifta

HUCAST has 182 HP and 42 DFP over HUmar while HUmar has 96 EVP over HUcast

HUCAST has THE highest HP and DFP of all playable classes

Mobius Plate is THE best DFP armor for Hunter class.

HUnewm/rl is overefficiant in TP usage.

[NER0]

HUcast or HUcaseal FTW

[MotleyKhon]

Robots are for children.
stats or no stats.
the REAL cool people play HUmar
:P
that a good enough argument?

[Chaos Rappy]

No, the COOOLEST people play HUnewearls. Check it. ;P