I found my first Mil Lilly today at 227 beats in Ultimate Letter from Lionel. Yay me!
I got a shiny red box for my efforts, and it was a force weapon (little cane icon next to it) and my lvl 93 force couldn't equip it yet! Not another blasted Storm wand then!
Eargerly anticipating what I thought to be a Psycho Wand (i dunno if you can get them with pinkal, but oh well)I teched it...to find a Cadaecus! "Wow" I thought, wtf is that?
I went to the item shop to start selling off the crap I garnered in my caves run (we can see where this is going now

) ....and I sold it! I. Sold. My. RARE!

Aaargh. If i knew how to make that emoticon with a guy hitting another guy with a hammer I'd use that!
So...are CADAECUS's rare? uber-rare? common-rare?
And PLEASE tell me your tales of lost rares (no porkies please!) so you can make me feel a BIT better

...the best rare I ever got was a Mace of Adaman...common as crap I presume on some section IDs!