Originally Posted by
Raxrenol
I've read through all your supporting quotes and I'm very impressed at the length at which you go to justify your points. However I do feel you segregate the types of people who'd view this thread into categories that are too extreme on either end. Yes, players who have absolutely no knowledge of Japanese wouldn't be able to fully understand a Japanese player's reply, maybe a disclaimer should be put up in the opening post to caution against going overboard. Similarly, a player fluent in Japanese would have no need for this thread, but that much is obvious.
The recommended phrases here do help to quickly get a message across though, and there have been numerous accounts of people having conversations with Japanese players over Google translate, so I wouldn't say someone without Japanese knowledge is completely helpless.
But more to the point, the real merits of this thread come to those who know the basics of Japanese, or are moderately skilled at it. Say someone who took a couple courses over a school break or did a few modules for interest. This person would have a base grasp of hiragana, katakana, some kanji, but he'd probably not have the vocabulary to express a wide variety of useful phrases for in-game situations. That's where this thread comes in.
Additionally, someone who's learning Japanese but simply does not have the time or motivation for a full time pursuit in the language can benefit in the interim by having a one-stop go-to guide for all the phrases he may find useful, and then proceed to focus on honing his Japanese later through professional lessons. Games are a great way to learn a language, playing online games while growing up greatly strengthened my grasp of English (I'm not a native speaker) through reading and application. There can be many ways to learn a language other than the conventional means.
My point is, there are many degrees of people in between the two extremes you've listed that could benefit from this thread (like me), thus I'd say saging it would be a tad overzealous.
True, this is very prevalent behavior in Japan, but to say that all of them don't care about other people around them is over generalizing. There are a decent number of friendly Japanese players who do try to speak to foreigners, as many scenarios on this forum can attest, so again I'd refrain from lumping every Japanese player into one big socially apathetic stereotype.
Connect With Us