This good enough?

[Syklo]

It's not good if you can't play it right well.

What's good is what you can use effectively.

[DreamState83]

It's not good if you can't play it right well.

What's good is what you can use effectively.

There is no way to play anything to its potential until you practice

[Ueno54]

Use Deadly Archer and watch everything die.

[SociableTyrannosaur]

It's not good if you can't play it right well.

What's good is what you can use effectively.

that's a ridiculous statement.

Why would you be able to play a female newman Hu/Fi better than a male cast Hu/Fi?

=/

You're smart enough not to say stuff like that.

[~Aya~]

that's a ridiculous statement.

Why would you be able to play a female newman Hu/Fi better than a male cast Hu/Fi?

=/

You're smart enough not to say stuff like that.

<--- Newman female Hu-Fi ^~^...

[Syklo]

that's a ridiculous statement.

Why would you be able to play a female newman Hu/Fi better than a male cast Hu/Fi?

=/

You're smart enough not to say stuff like that.

if the newearl played better than the male cast, i.e. that cast player sucked badly.
I'm not sure what you're getting at, since stats shouldn't matter to "play better"

[Meji]

Go newman if you prefer how it looks.

More love for us newmen! <3

[SociableTyrannosaur]

if the newearl played better than the male cast, i.e. that cast player sucked badly.
I'm not sure what you're getting at, since stats shouldn't matter to "play better"

Player's skill level isn't a variable when the only difference between two characters is stats.

If a single player were to run Hu/Fi, male cast is always a better choice than female newman. Aesthetics and skill level aren't a factor. You know that.

[Syklo]

Player's skill level isn't a variable when the only difference between two characters is stats.

If a single player were to run Hu/Fi, male cast is always a better choice than female newman. Aesthetics and skill level aren't a factor. You know that.

I think we're talking about different things....from what I can tell, you're describing a single-player&class;multi-character scenario, in which case there's no argument necessary.
My rebuttal was a multi-player;multi/single-character comparison, in which skill level IS a variable (across each player).
Initial response was in terms of single-player&character;multi-CLASS, in which skill level is a variable since gameplay/style is also a variable. Also merely a descriptive statement, not a comparison (I only said "good", not "good but ___ would be better"; if you can play a cast-FI well, ok; if you can play a newearl-FI well, ok. Whether you play one better (overall) than the other, idc.)



....And only now do I realise the OP said :

CAST - FIGHTER

Totally disregarded the race there

[SociableTyrannosaur]

Exactly.

If he has just asked fighter, this would have been a different conversation lol.

By glossing over the question you kinda missed the point of what was being said.

I wasn't talking in the scope of all classes and all class/race combinations. He's asking melee. He wants melee. Best STRICTLY melee race/gender is male cast.

That's as far as the conversation goes.